About
Welcome to Park Avenue Paninoteca, a vibrant culinary gem nestled in the heart of Rochester, NY. Located at 230 Monroe Ave, this restaurant is not merely a dining spot; it’s an experience that tantalizes the senses. With a reputation for exceptional service and a diverse menu, Park Avenue Paninoteca has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
Walking into Park Avenue Paninoteca, you are immediately enveloped in an atmosphere of warmth and elegance. Diners have praised the restaurant’s high-end ambiance, enhanced by charming light fixtures and a spacious bar. The attention to detail is commendable, with each table thoughtfully set, complete with bag hooks and electric sockets—indispensable features that elevate the dining experience.
The menu here is a delightful fusion of flavors, offering a little something for everyone. From the hand-breaded chicken cutlet to the flavorful clam chowder, each dish is crafted with care and freshly made to order. Customers rave about standout items, such as the Pesto Shrimp Bucatini, bursting with the aromatic tastes of basil and garlic, and the irresistibly crispy Arancini. There’s a palpable freshness in each bite that leaves you wanting more.
Take it from Huntz Shaikz, who celebrated an “amazing lunch” at Park Avenue Paninoteca, noting not just the quality of the food, but also the stellar service provided by staff like Joe. The attention given to guests creates a welcoming environment that invites you to return. And let’s not forget the sweet finish—customers leave raving about the homemade almond cookies and the decadent bread pudding dessert that takes the experience to another level.
As you prepare for a visit to Park Avenue Paninoteca, expect not just a meal, but a festive dining affair. Whether you're concluding a day at the nearby play museum or just seeking a cozy spot to enjoy a meal, this restaurant’s thoughtful ambiance and delicious offerings promise satisfaction. So grab your forks and get ready for a culinary journey that showcases the best of Rochester! You won't just eat; you'll savor!
“ Had an amazing lunch, all the tables were set with cute plates and everyone appreciates a bag hook and electric sockets at each table. Parking was easy right next to the restaurant. The ambiance is high end with the light fixtures and the huge bar. The menu has a little bit of everything and for a great price. Food was so tasty and freshly made to order. The hand breaded chicken cutlet was perfect. The cup of clam chowder warms your body up nicely from this winter weather. And not one item was too salty which is always a risk with things like that. So happy they got their own place again and will be coming back for dinner soon too! Thank you Joe for the exceptional service and delicious bread pudding dessert. We were very impressed by your hospitality from the very beginning to the end. ”
“ Visited Thursday April 10. Our server Nello recommended the Pesto Shrimp Bucatini and it was yummy, full of flavor from basil&garlic! Tried both Arancini, the Cajun Shrimp Appetizer and both were delish! Nello was professional, personable, prompt and courteous! We will be back soon to try the short ribs ”
“ One of my new favorite restaurants in Rochester! I came here for the first time today and was blown away by their food and service. I had their clam chowder which was amazing, followed by an even better panini. To top it all off I was given their homemade almond cookie to try and it was perfect! I would highly recommend going here if you are in the area, I know I will be back soon! ”
“ Great service, just after lunchtime. Great atmosphere and food. Relaxing after the play museum for sure. The food was well cooked and thought out! Highly recommend! Many options for such a small menu. ”
“ The service at this restaurant was outstanding—our server went above and beyond, even sharing the Spotify playlist when I asked about the fantastic music playing. Every song was a hit, and I immediately followed the playlist because their taste was impeccable. The food was exquisite; the salad appetizer was divine, bursting with fresh flavors. Our steak, paired with perfectly cooked potatoes, was a highlight, elevated by a mouthwatering butter topping that was surprisingly delightful. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, creating a perfect dining experience. I have zero complaints and would absolutely return! ”
“ Paninoteca is a great hidden gem with the best restaurant atmosphere I’ve ever experienced! They played soft music and had a movie on the bar tv. The waiter was kind and helpful. The food was delicious and we highly recommend the penne vodka; the pesto butter bread was delicious as well! Even their bathroom had an amazing atmosphere; it was sooo spacious and had colored lighting. Would definitely dine in here again next time we’re in Rochester! ”
“ This place prides itself as a panini restaurant, they even say how the Panini placed them on the map. This I found to be odd as I never cared for panini (warm squished sandwiches )... Clearly, I could NOT have been more wrong!! I do not know what sorcery is at play here, but this is the best panini I’ve ever had! I don’t like panini nor sandwiches (having grown up with South Asian dishes with more flavoUr). But this, this was impressive. It’s quite hard to put into words how amazing a “warm squished sandwich” can be, I wish I was more articulate at putting into words, what my taste buds experienced that day! It was so amazing, we came back for a 2nd round to take home for dinner. The only unfortunate (or fortunate?) thing is that this place is a bit hidden/inconspicuous even. Highly, highly recommended! Esp. If you DISLIKE panini, this is the place to experience what a panini SHOULD be. ”
“ Best Italian food experience I’ve had anywhere, ever. From the red sauce to the breading used on the fried mozzarella, everything tasted exactly like I grew up eating in my Sicilian-American household. Service was fantastic. Didn’t try any drinks but the bar looked well stocked. Will definitely be back!! ”